BoJack wakes on his deck with a paper mache of Todd's head on his own head. He takes it off and walks through the house where everyone is busy setting up for Todd and Emily's new cab company, Cabracadabra.
He goes out front and almost trips over a newspaper. This angers him so he calls the newspaper to complain. They transfer him to someone called The Closer. She asks how can she help him.
BoJack angrily tells her that he never subscribed to the LA Gazette, and he’s called multiple times about this issue before. The Closer assures him she’ll do everything she can to help him, and has a drone send him a glass of ice water. The Closer then notices he’s been subscribed for six months but hasn’t complained until now. BoJack then explains it wasn't a problem until Todd started making a paper mache head.
A flashback shows BoJack waking up to find a giant paper mache of Todd's head staring at him. Todd, who was wearing it, takes it off and tells BoJack hes been working on it for the last six months because someone has been stealing their food, and hopes that the head would scare whoever it was away. In the present, BoJack says Todd abandoned the project after he started working on Cabracadabra.
Cabracadabra is a cab company where woman drive other woman around, making them feel safe and preventing them from being harassed by men. This is what Todd and Emily tell Mr. Peanutbutter when they pitch it to him at his house. Of course, he’s on board with the idea. They are setting up shop at BoJack’s house because there no room at Mr. Peanutbutter’s house, as it’s filled with spaghetti strainers. Mr. Peanutbutter can’t remember why, but he’s certain the payoff will be huge.
Back to the present, the Closer asks BoJack why he agreed to let them use his house. BoJack admits its because he slept with Emily, who was Todd's old girlfriend, a few weeks prior.
There is a flashback to the end of Love And/Or Marriage, where Emily met up with BoJack at the bar after Todd got out of sleeping with her. She tells him she got thirsty, and when BoJack asks if Todd would want to join them, she says she’s tired of trying to figure out what Todd wants. After they sleep together, Emily said they should tell Todd, but BoJack tells her they shouldn’t.
When the two ran into each other when she and Todd first started setting up, they act awkward and deny knowing each other. Mr. Peanutbutter senses that something is going on, but decides that it’s because they all know Cabracadabra will be successful.
BoJack in the present tells the Closer that his friendship with Todd has been really strong at the moment, and he hasn’t been as mean to him as he has been in the past. The Closer guesses maybe he slept with Emily because deep down he feels like he doesn’t deserve Todd's friendship, but BoJack says it’s probably because he’s just a stupid asshole.
The Closer says when you do bad things, you always blame the bad thing and not yourself when people leave you, and she asks BoJack if he always keeps people at arms length, or afraid of being known. BoJack makes an excuse that he has to go to a marketing meeting, but asks her if he can call her back tomorrow. She says of course.
BoJack calls her back the next day and tells her about the meeting. Diane arrived late and explains why she is late despite nobody wanting to know. The meeting is about a new ad campaign for Secretariat, the "For Your Consideration" ads for the Oscars.
Lenny picks out the one he thinks is the best, but out of the multiple ads he brought in, BoJack finds a mirror ad - a reflective sheet that says "You Are Secretariat". He tells Lenny he likes it and thinks it’s powerful, and in the present he explains to the Closer he thought the other ads looked backwards, but there was something intimate about seeing himself in the mirror for who he really is.
Lenny tells BoJack that he likes it because he is Secretariat. BoJack asks wasn’t that the point of the movie, to inspire people, but Lenny says the reason they made the movie was to make a lot of money and win awards. He says if anyone looks at that ad, and thinks they could also be Secretariat, then there’s no point in giving him an Oscar. Ana tells BoJack to leave the decision making to the experts.
Afterwards, Ana and BoJack have sex in his car. In the present, he tells the Closer they have a complicated relationship. BoJack stops them having sex and asks why they never go back to her place. He tells Ana she controls everything about his life, but he knows nothing about her.
Ana sternly says he doesn’t what to know her, but BoJack pleads that he does. Ana says she knows him and this, what they're doing, is exactly what he wants. The Closer asks BoJack what he thinks she meant by that, but BoJack questions back why he’s still getting the La Gazette.
The Closer says maybe the newspaper reminds him of Todd's paper mache head, which he abandoned to work on his company with Emily, who BoJack slept with, and asks if that’s why he wants to cancel a bazooka the LA Gazette. BoJack denies this and says he wants to cancel his subscription because newspapers are dumb. The Closer asks if he has any guilt over sleeping with Emily. BoJack admits he has had trouble sleeping.
It cuts back to the night before the beginning of the episode. BoJack is tossing and turning as he hears Todd and Emily talking and laughing together. The two are playing Truth or Dare, and Emily picks truth. Todd asks Emily what's the worst thing she's done to someone lately, but she's saved from answering by BoJack who tells them that they’re keeping him up.
BoJack decides to sleep on his boat. However, he goes into the captain’s quarters and finds Character Actress Margo Martindale hiding out there, surrounded by food, and she points a bazooka in his face. He asks how long she’s been living there.
She explains ever since The Shot she’s been laying low. She disappeared for a little bit, and performed in regional theater, as she didn’t believe she’d have any chance of being discovered there. However, she was too good, and her performance got attention by the San Diego Union Tribune. She left and has been hiding out in BoJack's boat ever since - except for an arc she did on The Good Wife, which she was able to do by disappearing into the role. Margo Martindale tells him he knows too much, and attempts to use a smoke bomb on him, but it ends up being a plum.
BoJack goes back to his house to sleep on his deck. As he listens to Todd and Emily laughing, he puts the paper mache head on and goes to sleep.
The Closer says with all the turmoil he went through it would be nice to have soothing to depend on and would arrive at his doorstep every morning. BoJack tries stop tell her otherwise, but she cuts him off and asks what happened when he told Ana he wanted to know her.
Cut back to the two after they had sex in his car, BoJack tells Ana that he wants to know something about her if they're going to works together. Ana says that it doesn’t matter, she’s worked with guys like him before, and they need to keep a little distance. BoJack followed her home, and as he spied on her in her small apartment he saw her being normal. The Closer says that can be very intimate, but BoJack says it wasn’t a good intimate, and that its sad when you see someone for how they truly are because it ruins them.
The Closer asks if he has anyone to talk to about the feelings and issues he has. He is interrupted by Margo, who scares him by wearing the paper mache Todd head. She takes it off and tells him she was nominated for an award, so she has to take his boat out to international waters, and he never saw her. BoJack doesn’t care and shows her off as he’s on the phone.
BoJack tells the Closer that all he wants is to have control over his own life and that he wants to cancel the delivery of the LA Gazzete. The Closer tells him that he doesn't want to do that, and tells him control is a myth, and you just have to go with what life throws at you, convincing him to renew his subscription. BoJack thanks her and assays she’s given him a lot to think about, and he hangs up.
Inside, Emily asks Todd if she can talk to him. She tells Todd he should run the company without her, saying he really doesn’t need her anyways and she can’t work here. An upset Todd asks if he did something, but Emily assures him it’s her, and BoJack. Todd asks what happened. Emily says she hasn’t been a good friend to him, and that things happened, and that BoJack hasn’t been a very good friend to him either. A downed Todd accepts, and assures Emily he wants her to keep her share of money. Emily tells him he’s sweet, and he shouldn’t waste it on people who don’t deserve it.
BoJack goes to visit Ana. She demands him to leave, but he tells her he knows she wants to remain mysterious but control is a myth, and he wants to sleep with her in her bed and wake up with her, he really likes her and isn’t afraid to know her. Ana is touched by this and accepts.
BoJack also says he wants to go with the mirror ads for Secretariat. He demands it’s his campaign and he doesn’t want to be pushed around, which impresses Ana, and she agrees.
However, the ad is a complete fail, as the billboard just reflects the sky. Lenny is annoyed he spent thousands of dollars to tell people to nominate the sky for an Oscar, BoJack admits he didn’t think it through, and Diane realizes when the sun sets and reflects off the billboard it could be a huge problem. Lenny sarcastically says at least BoJack got what he wanted.
- Cabracadabra's slogan "Cabracadabra: We Wanna Reeach Out And Grab You is a reference to the Steve Miller Band Song "Abracadabra".
- Specifically, it references the lyric "Abra abracadabra, I wanna reach out and grab you".
- Ana reveals she's divorced, has a son she can’t see, and her favorite fruit is honeydew.
- This makes her the second character next to Mr. Peanutbutter who admits they love honeydew, a fruit BoJack detests.