Marcie is shown to be very jealous of all of BoJack's other relationships and psychotic in her obsession with BoJack. She keeps a scrapbook with photographs of all of BoJack's previous relationships and drew x's over their eyes and creepily stalked their home addresses as well. She lies as a means of keeping BoJack around longer.
Marcie was the borderline psychotic and deranged president of BoJack's fan club. He slept with her in 1999 and the two never spoke again after that until Hollyhock contacted BoJack to find her birth mother. Marcie lies about being Hollyhock's mother as a means of keeping BoJack around longer.
Hollyhock makes this discovery of Marcie's lying after finding a picture of a young Marcie at a movie premiere of the movie Autumn in New York which came out in August 2000.
Hollyhock was confused as to why someone would wear a summer dress to a movie titled Autumn in New York only to find out the movie had not been released in the season of Autumn at all despite it's title and decides to investigate further.
Marcie shows no signs of being eight months pregnant in the photo and looks nothing like a woman who would be expecting in that time frame. Hollyhock was born a month later after the movie was released, in September, of that same year. This evidence reveals Marcie is not Hollyhock's mother after all.
BoJack uses the method of distracting Marcie to steal her scrapbook to find out the other potential candidates who could be Hollyhock's mother by having sex with her behind the couch while she recites obscure Horsin' Around trivia which BoJack quizzes her on.
Marcie is a middle-aged woman who has wavy auburn hair with light brown tints which she clips back into a messy bun with a silver hair accessory. She wears brown glasses and has freckles going across her cheekbones. She is seen wearing a lilac button down shirt with an open maroon cardigan and a long blue and white tie-die skirt and gold sandals.
In the year 2000 she wore a yellow floral with a maroon belt summer dress with white wedge strappy sandals and her wavy hair down and clipped back with the silver hair clip. She is seen without her glasses.