|“|| Like, sometimes I have this tiny voice in the back of my head that goes, like, "Hey, everyone hates you! And they're not wrong to feel that way!" [...]
That voice, the one that tells you you're worthless and stupid and ugly? It goes away, right? It's just, like, a dumb teenage-girl thing, but then it goes away?
—Hollyhock, "Stupid Piece of Sh*t"
Hollyhock Manheim-Mannheim-Guerrero-Robinson-Zilberschlag-Hsung-Fonzerelli-McQuack is an anthropomorphic teenage horse. After making a brief appearance in the season three finale, she was introduced as a new supporting character in the fourth season of BoJack Horseman. Initially believed to be BoJack Horseman's daughter, it was eventually revealed she is his half-sister, sired by BoJack's father Butterscotch with his human mistress Henrietta Platchkey.
According to her birth certificate, she was originally named "Girl Horse", before being adopted and raised by eight gay fathers.
Hollyhock is a teenage female horse. She has light brown fur, a chestnut brown mane with bangs that are worn parted, a white diamond shaped mark on her forehead similar to BoJack's, lighter brown fur on her mouth and nostrils, pointy ears, and lighter brown freckles on her face, neck, chest, and upper arms.
According to BoJack she is about 5'8. She has a chubby build, although in the later part of Season 4 Hollyhock slowly loses weight from episode to episode by unknowingly drinking drugged coffee by Beatrice Horseman. It becomes the most noticeable in "Lovin that cali lifestyle!!". She returns to her normal body shape by the end of “What Time Is It Right Now”.
Hollyhock wears a teal sweater with a dark teal collar and sleeve cuffs, dark grey ripped jeans, and pale yellow sneakers with pink socks. She also has two piercings on her right ear, and she also wears a double-stranded beaded necklace with a simple gold feather-shaped pendant.
People say she looks a lot like BoJack, which is why she initially thought he was her father.
Hollyhock was conceived sometime in December 1999. Butterscotch Horseman had cheated on his wife, Beatrice Horseman, with their maid, Henrietta Platchkey. Beatrice is initially angry, but she talks to Henrietta, who is struggling to earn money to pay tuition for nursing school. Beatrice says she'll pay for her tuition and convinces her to give the baby up for adoption, saying she doesn't want her to end up like her (giving up her life and dreams for the baby and letting Butterscotch poison her life).
Hollyhock is born September 24, 2000. We then see Henrietta wanting to hold the newly born foal and crying as she is taken away by Beatrice, implying in actual fact that she wanted to keep her daughter. Hollyhock was originally named "Girl Horse", but she was later adopted by eight gay men, and renamed Hollyhock Manheim-Mannheim-Guerrero-Robinson-Zilbersclag-Hsung-Fonzerelli-McQuack.
Hollyhock first appears in That Went Well. Princess Carolyn had just opened her own management agency. As she sits in her new office, Judah informs her that someone is trying to contact BoJack Horseman and that she sounds like a teenage girl.
Princess Carolyn, who had been fired by BoJack a few episodes ago and has moved on from him, tells Judah to tell her she doesn't work for BoJack anymore. Judah hangs up the call. We then see who was on the other line; a female teenage horse, who appears sad at not being able to reach BoJack.
After returning to Mr Peanutbutter’s house, she knocks him out with chloroform. After he wakes up, he tries to fend her off with the pool net, but she assured him she won’t hurt him. She introduces herself as Hollyhock Manheim-Mannheim-Guerrero-Robinson-Zilberschlag-Fonzerelli-McQuack. Todd asks her to repeat her name twice and is confused by her last name, she explains she has eight dads because she was adopted by eight gay men who live in a polyamorous relationship.
Hollyhock says ever since she was a baby people have always told her she looks like BoJack Horseman, and she came to LA to see if he’s her biological father. She bought a spy kit for it, and she now enjoys knocking people out with chloroform. She thought Todd could help her because in BoJack’s book he said they live together.
Todd informs her he doesn’t live there anymore, and BoJack has been gone for a year and no one knows where he is. Hollyhock says she doesn’t have to meet him, she just wants a DNA sample, like a piece of hair. Todd says BoJack‘s house might have something, and Hollyhock knocks him out again.
When Todd wakes up the two are in BoJack’s house, where it is discovered BoJack has returned, and he is fast asleep on the couch in his underwear. BoJack is in a deep enough sleep for Hollyhock to yank out a strand of his hair. Hollyhock says “Ok, let’s blow “ and the word blow wakes up BoJack, saying to save some for him. BoJack asks who she is and she introduces herself. Todd lies and says she’s his new maid. After having a short somber conversation with Todd, and begins to question why he got him a maid, Hollyhock knocks out BoJack with chloroform and tells Todd to take the hair to get it tested.
However, when Todd gets to the lab he finds out he needs a sample from Hollyhock too, and, after going to a restaurant with Courtney Portnoy he goes back to discover she has not cleaned up at all, instead she has been going through BoJack’s stuff to learn about him. She also ate a box of doughnuts, got sleepy, and took a nap which makes Todd certain the two are related.
She doesn’t want to yank out a strand of hair because it sounds painful and asks if they can just use Todd’s hair. The doctor tells him no and Todd runs back and gets a hair sample from a comb she has. BoJack complains to Todd his new maid isn’t doing her job and he’ll fire her, and Todd convinces BoJack to get drunk and fall asleep, and while he does that he’ll get the maid to clean. However, Todd ends up cleaning the house while Hollyhock eats, reads a magazine, and goes on her phone, and watches TV. When Todd has to leave again, he tells her to stay there and he’ll get the DNA test later, but he sees that she has fallen asleep.
Todd ends up giving the hair to Diane, who is trying to write a juicy story for the website she works on, lying to her saying Channing Tatum has an illegitimate daughter with a Cordovian refuge and the hair samples are from Channing and the baby. He tells Diane to call him first if the hairs are a match. Later, Diane confirms the DNA is indeed a match.
Todd goes to BoJack’s house and discovers BoJack sent her to Channing Tatum’s house to clean in order to thank him for collecting his mail while he was gone. Todd finds Hollyhock on Channing’s couch, reading a magazine with a feather duster in her hand. She asks him about the DNA and says she thinks she nailing being a maid. Todd lies and says it’s not a match. Hollyhock feels bad for coming here. Diane then comes to the front door outside, and Todd pretends to be Channing.
Diane tries to interview him, and through this Hollyhock learns the DNA sample is a match. While Todd talks to Diane, Hollyhock leaves through the glass doors in the room. Later, after Todd tells BoJack Hollyhock is his daughter, and after having a conversation with him about his asexuality, he leaves, Hollyhock returns to BoJack’s house again, and she and BoJack are alone together.
The next episode begins with them sitting apart from each other on the couch, awkwardly BoJack tells how how he’s bad news and would be a horrible father. Hollyhock doesn’t care and says she doesn’t want another dad, she wants to know who her birth mom is. She asks who he had sex with in December 1999, and BoJack says he banged a lot of chicks at that period of time.
However, he suspects a woman named Marcie, because she was a “poking holes in the condoms type”, although she was “a nutter” and “a good lay”. BoJack agrees to take her to Marcie’s apartment the next morning to meet her, and Hollyhock says after that she’ll leave him alone. However she is able to guilt him into letting her stay at his house for the night instead of her hostile, which is in a bad part of town.
The next morning, BoJack wakes up to find that Hollyhock has set the microwave on fire for trying to make him breakfast, a Pop-tart, to thank him for letting her stay there. She put it in tinfoil to make it “popcorn style “. He forgives her however because making food is impossible . He also eats the charred Pop-tart on the way to driving Hollyhock to Marcie’s place.
BoJack explains Marcie was the president of his fan club. They arrive at Marci’s apartment, and she tells BoJack she knew he would come back and says she did give a baby up for adoption seventeen years ago. Hollyhock hugs her “mother”. Marcie says she tied to call BoJack but the number he gave her was for a sandwich shop in Temecula. BoJack lies and says he would have called her, but 9/11 happened.
Later, Marcie shows them a scrapbook of all the women BoJack had been with and their home addresses due to the fact she was so in love with BoJack and he never called back, which made her jealous. Hollyhock excuses herself to use the bathroom, and then calls BoJack into the bathroom telling Marcie it’s a dad bathroom thing.
Hollyhock tells BoJack that Marcie is not her mom, because she found a photo of her from the premiere of the movie Autumn in New York, which premired August of 2000. Hollyhock was born the following month, in September, and Marcie does not look a woman would be showing at eight months pregnancy.
She tells BoJack they have to get the scrapbook, as it has every woman BoJack slept with and that will help them find her mom. BoJack agree to distract Marcie, but as Hollyhock sneaks into the living room to get the book, to her horror and disgust BoJack and Marcie are having sex behind the couch and BoJack is quizzing Marcie on random Horsin' Around trivia.
The next woman they go to is Tilda Madison, a hairless cat who is the Time Medium on CBS. She did, in fact, get pregnant, but she got an abortion, with BoJack sending her a check for half of it. BoJack says that’s good because you don’t want any little BoJacks running around because the last thing the world needs is more of him. Hollyhock is offended, and BoJack says he likes her but he would go back and try to prevent this. Hollyhock storms out angrily at this comment.
While driving away from Tilda’s set, BoJack tried to apologize, Hollyhock sarcastically apologizes that he has to interact with the women he was shitty to. BoJack says he doesn’t know why they’re doing it because she’ll never switch bodies with her mom or anything. Hollyhock commands BoJack to pull over, and she says she can find her mom on her own now that she has the book. She leaves and tells BoJack to have a bad life. He responds with “Joke’s on you! I already have one!”
However, BoJack returns home and misses her, so he goes to every woman he slept with and asks them if he got them pregnant and gave a baby up for adoption seventeen years ago. Neither he or Hollyhock find her mom.
Late in the day BoJack finds Hollyhock and tells her what he did. Hollyhock says this was stupid and that she shouldn’t have come here because she doesn’t need a Mom because she did great with eight dads.
She gets upset over wanting a mom because that means her dads weren’t good enough for her, but they were. BoJack tells her to give up for looking for enough, because it’ll never be enough. Hollyhock starts crying and he, not knowing how to comfort her and asks what her dads tell her. She says they tell her it’s OK to cry and she shouldn’t feel bad about feeling bad. BoJack tells her she can stay with him a little longer, but Hollyhock questions how they’re going to find her mom.
BoJack lies and says her mother is “Carla Mercedes Benz Brown”. Hollyhock says that’s a weird name, BoJack retorts by saying Hollyhock is the one with a weird name. Hollyhock hopes that the first thing she and her birth mother could talk about when they finally meet for the first time.
In “Thoughts and Prayers”, we see Hollyhock and BoJack driving back to his house, with Hollyhock amazed that she knows the name of her birth mom. However, two days later at breakfast BoJack admits that he lied about her mother and that he doesn't know who it is. He promises that he’ll do everything he can to help her find her birth mom, but from his experience with his mother he says moms aren’t that great. Hollyhock asks if she could meet her, and BoJack lies that she’s dead.
Fifteen minutes later Hollyhock asks about what happened to the Fudgsicles she got, and BoJack confesses that his mom is not actually dead. Hollyhock says she wants to meet her and asks where she lives. He tells her she lives in a luxurious nursing home, but he cannot remember the name, which offends Hollyhock. BoJack reluctantly agrees to take Hollyhock to visit his mother, and he says he won’t lie to her anymore. Hollyhock asks if he ate the last Fudgsicle. To which, BoJack lies and says he didn't then a few minutes later admits, in fact, he did eat it.
BoJack finds out from Princess Carolyn that the nursing home his mother is living at is called Walnut Springs, and it is in Santa Barbara. When they arrive, Hollyhock questions BoJack how he didn’t feel any guilt about leaving his mother here. BoJack says she didn’t know his mom. His mother, Beatrice, was verbally abusive to him throughout his childhood and is a big factor in how he became so screwed up.
The two find a now elderly Beatrice, but she doesn’t recognize BoJack and calls him “Henrietta”. BoJack is annoyed by this and thinks she is just pretending to not recognize him due to her bitter attitude she always had towards him. However, she somehow recognizes Hollyhock, saying “Oh hello! It’s You!”. BoJack is distraught that his mother cannot recognize him. Hollyhock sits down next across from Beatrice and tells BoJack she’d like some orange juice as well.
Later, when BoJack comes back with the orange juice, he sees Hollyhock talking with Beatrice. Beatrice tells Hollyhock she can’t believe she came back, and that she looks “just like him”.
A male doctor tells BoJack that his mother has dementia, and their visit has made her the most responsive she’s been in weeks, and them visiting on a daily basis will help her. BoJack refuses, but the doctor says she will not live for another 10 years. BoJack is fine with this and tells Hollyhock it’s time for them to leave. Hollyhock demands they visit her every week, because she’s his mother, and dementia is hereditary, so they might have it one day and they would want someone to take care of them. BoJack reluctantly agrees.
The next week, Beatrice shows Hollyhock a photo album, with BoJack still bitter about the fact she can’t remember him. After he leaves out of boredom. Hollyhock points out a picture of Beatrice, and she tells her that was from her debutante ball, and Hollyhock exclaims how beautiful she was. Beatrice tells Hollyhock she could be thin too, just go easy on the sweets and when she goes somewhere she should gallop and not walk. Hollyhock responds by saying “Way harsh, Grammy Gram”.
A week later, BoJack brings a DVD set of “Horsin' Around” (which Hollyhock at first thinks is a “thin hard book”) and he puts on the episode “I’m Ready For My Close-up, Mr. Dementia” to learn how to deal with Beatrice. To his shock, Beatrice recognizes BoJack on the TV and laughs at the episode, despite in the past criticizing and dismissing it. During their next visit BoJack goes outside upset over his situation with his mother. Hollyhock wonders how they can get her to connect the BoJack from the show to the BoJack that visits her every week. BoJack then gets the idea to put on a live episode of Horsin’ Around at the nursing home, and when his mother finally recognizes him, he’ll sit next to her, squeeze her hand, and say “Fuck you, Mom”. Hollyhock disagrees with this, but BoJack has already set his mind on it.
One week later, BoJack has set up a fake episode of Horsin’ Around, with Hollyhock playing Olivia by wearing a mop for a blonde wig. She is still skeptical and nervous about BoJack’s plan, but he tells her it’ll be ok, as long as she enunciates her lines. After Beatrice arrives they begin, but Beatrice is confused and scared by what they’re doing, and she ends up having a meltdown where she shoves other elders, and she is wheeled out of the room.
Beatrice is kicked out for being violent, and the doctor from before says due to her rapid deterioration, she should live with them. Hollyhock agrees and says Beatrice can have the guest bedroom and she’ll sleep on the couch. BoJack reluctantly agrees. While Beatrice is being moved in, with the help of her new nurse Tina Bear, BoJack goes out on his deck and Hollyhock follows. He says his mother is going to die and she’ll never know how much he hates her. Hollyhock says she probably did because she read his novel, and assures him Beatrice will have bad days and good days, and maybe one day she will recognize him. The episode ends with BoJack putting his hand on Hollyhock’s shoulder, with some hesitation.
In “Stupid Piece of Sh*t”, after BoJack wakes up in the morning (and we hear start to hear his self-deprecating innner monologue) Hollyhock says they need milk. She asks BoJack if she can take the car. BoJack’s inner monologue tells him that he doesn’t want her getting her grubby hands all over his stuff, but he quickly takes this back and tells himself she’s his daughter. But then he tells himself if Hollyhock leaves, he’ll be stuck with his mother. However, if he goes to get it he fears his mother will try to poison Hollyhock against him. He still says he’ll get the milk. He ends up spending the whole day at a bar and returns home drunk and ashamed. Hollyhock is annoyed by this too.
At breakfast the next day she reveals Tina got the milk and is making them breakfast. Beatrice tells BoJack (Henrietta) he should make a healthy breakfast for the baby, because “no one likes a fatty patty”, which makes Hollyhock look uncomfortable.
Hollyhock has Tina get Beatrice a baby horse doll because she kept asking where the baby was, and it was getting depressing to look at her. BoJack is offended that his mother loves the baby doll so much due to how she abused him as a child.
Later, while also making eggs, she makes Hollyhock coffee, to which she replies is amazing. She is also proud of Beatrice of being able to make eggs. Beatrice comments on how well behaved her baby is. Hollyhock says it’s because she’s a good mother, BoJack tells her to not say that, and she’s not really like this . Hollyhock says to let go of whatever beef he has with his mom, because now she’s just a sweet confused old lady.
BoJack is convinces the real her is in there somewhere. Beatrice tells them to stop shouting in front of the baby. BoJack angrily questions where that good parenting was 50 years ago, and an offended Beatrice says he’s unfit to be a parent. While BoJack tells himself this is true in his head, he takes the doll from her and starts tossing it around, sarcastically asking if leaving the baby alone and not feeding it or changing it would make him a good mother, or if telling it for 18 years how it embarrasses him and his life would have been better if it wasn’t born. Beatrice tries to get the doll back and called him a worthless waste of her husband’s jizims. BoJack then throws the doll over his deck, which leads Beatrice to scream and start sobbing, due to her previous childhood trauma of her baby doll being burned. BoJack is at first proud, but Hollyhock is ashamed of him, and BoJack immediately feels regret.
Beatrice is sad until BoJack gets Mr Peanutbutter to find the doll in Felicity Huffman’s yard, while also agreeing to be on her show (FHBA) to apologize for always throwing his crap over his deck. BoJack tells Mr. Peanutbutter that he feels like Hollyhock is getting attached to him, and he’ll just screw everything up and she’ll hate him. Mr Peanutbutter assures him that everyone deserves to be loved.
After giving the doll back to Beatrice, he sees Hollyhock by the pool, lighting matches and throwing them into the pool. The voice in BoJack’s head tells him his poison is already in her and he’ll destroy her like everyone else in his life. He goes to talk to her, and she asks where he goes when he disappears all day. He says he just drive around, sometimes he’ll go to a bar, or just stop by the side of the road and stares into the distance. Hollyhock why and BoJack just shrugs. She asks if he would rather do that then spend time with her. She says she knows he didn’t ask for this dorky 17 year old, and she apologizes for being annoying. BoJack quickly reassured her that he likes having her here, and he’s just a shitty person, and she’s allowed to be mad at him, but whatever he does is not her fault.
Hollyhock reveals that sometimes she has a tiny voice in the back of her head that says everyone hates her and they’re not wrong to feel that way. BoJack says he knows what she means. Hollyhock then asks “That voice, the one that tells you you're worthless and stupid and ugly? It goes away, right? It's just, like, a dumb teenage-girl thing, but then it goes away?”. BoJack says yes.
In “The Judge”, she comes with BoJack to the set of Felicity Hoffman’s TV show he’s guest starring on, which he assumes is some sort of crime show. On the ride there, she talks about sending in a form, and if her mom wants to meet her, then she’ll meet her, and she worries about her not wanting to meet her and feeling the hot sting of rejection . She also says she’s really wanted to get out of the house lately because being cooped up has made her really fidgety lately, like she has little tiny bugs crawling on the inside of her skin.
On set, An intern named Miles offers her some water, and Hollyhock is flattered, although BoJack retorts that’s his job. It is learned FHBA stands for Felicity Hoffman’s Booty Academy, and it involves judging other girls butts (although Felicity claims otherwise, saying its about judging character and inspiring female leadership).
During a break, Hollyhock asks if they could go home, because being all the skinny LA girls make her feel like a blob. BoJack must shoot for another 10 hours, which confuses Hollyhock as to why. Sir Mix a Lot, who is also a judge as he is famous for not being able to lie, questions why she isn’t in school, and after BoJack says he should mind his own business Hollyhock reveals she graduated early and is taking a gap year. Displeased with having to stay in a “butt infested warehouse” Hollyhock leaves. However she runs into Miles and they hang out together.
The next day, Hollyhock returns home, and BoJack questions where she’s been as Beatrice announces she’ll make coffee. Hollyhock says she has been with Mikes the entire time. She says he’s sweet and they have a real connection (There is also a bit of an implication they slept together, but it is unknown if it was sexual or not). BoJack says she’ll never hear from him again, however Hollyhock says Miles promised he’d text her. BoJack refuses to believe this, and says if he does text her, he’ll do a thousand push ups. During this, Miles was texting Hollyhock, and asks her out to a party. BoJack attempts to do push-ups but gives up after one. Miles then sends Hollyhock another text saying he wants to spend the day with her.
BoJack asks if she wants breakfast, but Hollyhock rejects, saying she’s good with her coffee, and she’ll be home for dinner. After she leaves, we see Beatrice on the floor next to BoJack doing push-ups with ease, saying she could do this all day.
At night, Hollyhock returns home. BoJack is sitting in the dark across from her and says “Hello Hollyhock”. He tries to turn the lamp on next to him, but the bulb is burns out. He goes to get a new one , and greets Hollyhock again after successfully turning on the light.
Hollyhock questions what he’s doing, to which BoJack replies he’s keeping her safe, while also looking dramatic. Hollyhock says she told him she would be home late, and BoJack demands that it’s his house and she has to asks permission to stay out late. Hollyhock tells him he’s not her dads.
BoJack says he’s just looking out for her, and is still suspicious of Miles. Hollyhock, as she puts more sugar in her coffee, says there’s nothing to worry about because they like each other. BoJack retorts they like each other now, and begins to say something but hesitates. He then says Miles is a teenage boy whos job is to hang around hot women in skimpy outfits, and then says “You think he’s gonna want..” but quickly cuts himself off. Hollyhock questions if he’s implying she’s not attractive enough. BoJack defends himself by saying she’s the one who said she was a blob.
Hollyhock, distraught, asks BoJack if he thinks she’s a blob, and angrily questions why he would call his daughter one. BoJack says she said it too, but she says she felt like a blob. She angrily questions BoJack again if he thinks she’s a blob. BoJack calmly says that he just thinks LA is a superficial town and she should be careful. Hollyhock angrily says Miles likes her just the way she is, and that’s the kind of person she wants to spend her time with.
She begins to storm out, but BoJack tries to stop her, saying “wait, wait, wait!”, but Hollyhock heard this the wrong way and says “I get it! It’s my weight!” and slams the door as she leaves.
When BoJack his dilemma to Diane, she says he shouldn’t have called her a blob. BoJack says they’re both blobs. Diane says he shouldn’t call women blobs in general. BoJack still thinks Miles is up to something. When Diane asks why it’s so hard to believe someone could genuinely like his daughter, BoJack exclaims that she’s like him.
Diane says this whole thing may be more about him, although BoJack claims it’s about him trying to fix things with Hollyhock. Diane suggests an open conversation, but BoJack rejects this, saying it’s “too Diane-y”. He gets the idea to prove that Miles is a jerk so Hollyhock will like him again.
He goes to a contestant named Goldie and tells her she’ll advance to the final round if she seduces the PA. Later she tells him she had sex with him, to BoJack’s confusion because he only wanted her to seduce him so he can catch him admitting he would sleep with her. BoJack learns from Miles that he is an intern not a PA, so the contestant slept with someone else. When the other judges learn about what BoJack did, he is fired.
As he leaves, Miles catches up to him. He says if he didn’t want him dating Hollyhock he could have told him, and they could’ve worked out some sort of deal. BoJack questions what he means.
Miles says he has his own screenplay that could really go somewhere. He gives it to BoJack and tells him if he gives it to someone he would never talk to Hollyhock again, showing that BoJack was right about Miles being a jerk.
BoJack tells this to Diane, saying he was hoping that he would be wrong about Miles,m. He says he won’t tell Hollyhock, because she’s smart and she’ll figure it out eventually, and that if she believes someone can love her for who she really is, he won’t take that away from her.
At night, BoJack comes he to find Hollyhock sitting on his couch with the TV on. He apologizes for being an asshole, and asks her what she’s doing. She says she’s seeing how fast she can change the TV channels, and earlier she found all the loose change in the house and organized them in alphabetical order by year.
She then asks if a guy like Miles could really ever love a girl like her. BoJack tells her he was just jealous that she was spending so much time with him. Hollyhock says he hasn’t texted her at all that day, and she’s been trying to distract herself. BoJack tells her to forget him, because she’ll meet many more guys who will fall madly in love with her. Hollyhock thinks she might have scared him off.
She asks BoJack if he ever gets the feeling that to know you more is to love you less. BoJack goes on to tell her that she is an amazing woman and to never settle for someone who likes the idea of her. When he tells her she’s funny, kind, and clever, Hollyhock also asks if she’s pretty. BoJack becomes flustered and asks what she wants him to say, because obviously he thinks she’s beautiful. Hollyhock is flattered.
BoJack recommends they go get some ice cream, but Hollyhock says no. BoJack then recommends pizza, but Hollyhock says she’s not hungry. The episode ends with Hollyhock going back to flipping channels while BoJack looks at her.
Hollyhock does not appear in “Ruthie”, but BoJack and Diane go to the county courthouse to find her birth certificate, by asking them for all the birth certificates from the day Hollyhock was born, find hers, and see what it says for “mother”. BoJack says he wants to do right by Hollyhock, but Diane doubts how his plan will work. BoJack assumes they’ll let him do it because he’s famous. BoJack also notes Hollyhock couldn’t come with him because that morning she really got into counting her teeth. He assumes it’s a teenager thing.
BoJack is frustrated by the long lines and all the paperwork, so he gives up and goes home.
“Lovin that cali lifestyle!!” begins from Hollyhock’s point of view, as she, BoJack, Beatrice, and Beatrice’s nurse Tina playing Uno. We see that Hollyhock is having some sort of an episode, as she is dizzy and disoriented, and she is acting a bit anxious and antsy, as she is tapping her feet and scratching her knuckles and neck. She has also lost a lot of weight, as her clothes are noticeably baggy, she is visually much skinnier and there appears to be some loose skin around her formally plump belly.
When BoJack sees her scratching herself, he asks if she’s ok with a look of concern on his face. Hollyhock insists she’s fine and says she just needs a glass of water. However on the way to the kitchen her dizziness comes back, and she ends up loosing grip of the glass and it falls and breaks, with a shard cutting her forehead. BoJack hears this and after seeing she cut herself, he jokes she just needs some alcohol to forget about it. Hollyhock announces she’ll be right back and goes upstairs to BoJack’s bathroom.
As she enters the bathroom, her dizziness and disorientation becomes worse, as she can barely keep her balance or concentration. She tries to get a bandaid from BoJack’s medicine cabinet, but when she grabs the box she ends up knocking over and spilling multiple prescription pills he had in there. Her phone vibrates and she sees through her blurred vision she got a text from her “Papa Otto”, one of her dads. He asks “how’re you doing, honey?”. Hollyhock quickly covers up her cut with her bangs and sends him the selfie with a text reading “lovin that cali lifestyle!!!” before she passes out and collapses.
BoJack hears her collapse from downstairs, and he calls an ambulance to take her to the hospital. At the hospital, he is trying to remember her last names so that he can prove he’s her legal guardian, because he is not allowed to see her or get any information about her condition if he can’t . After failing to bribe the receptionist, he suddenly remembers all of her last names and tells her. He also says she’s 5’8, is 17 years old, and her birthday is in September. He goes on to say other things about her, like how she looks like him, that’s she loves apples but hates applesauce, she’s funny but not in a mean way, and how she’s sweet and “has this smile”, showing how BoJack has grown found and attached to her.
The receptionist still refuses to let him see her, and tells him to have a seat, much to his frustration. BoJack waits in the waiting room for hours, and he ends up falling asleep.
When he wakes up, he sees a group of eight men talking to each other, and they mention Hollyhock. He goes to the, and learns they’re her father’s, and they each introduce themselves:
- Jose Guerrero, a Mexican brown bear
- Steve Mannheim, “the wrong Mannheim to mess with”
- Dashawn Manheim, “probably the right Manheim to mess with” unless it’s in a dance battle
- Cupe Robinson III, he dislikes BoJack and was against Hollyhock finding him from the start
- Otto Zilberschlag, a Polish man, who was formerly a huge fan of BoJack, but after this incident he’s now just a regular fan
- Gregory Hsung, a lizard who knows of BoJack but not from his work, as his “deal” is that he only watches foreign films.
- Arturo "Ice Man" Fonzarelli, who dresses and speaks in a greaser-like fashion, and people call him the “ice man” because he’s so cool
- Quackers McQuack, a duck who says quack a lot.
BoJack asks them if she’s ok. Steve angrily says she’s lucky to be alive, and it is revealed Hollyhock overdosed on amphetamines. BoJack is shocked by this, saying he had no idea. Dashawn questions how he didn’t, as Hollyhock is now as thin as a pole. They are all angry at BoJack, saying Hollyhock said he was taking care of her, and they all blame him for her getting hooked on amphetamines, with Steve saying he’s lucky they don’t call the police.
BoJack tries to calm the dads down, saying he’ll leave for a bit to give Hollyhock time to rest before he talks to her again. The dads angrily reject this, and forbid him from ever seeing Hollyhock again.
After they leave BoJack in the waiting room, he gets a look of shock on his face, and he drives back home. He runs upstairs to his bathroom, and ,to his horror, he finds his opened and spilled medicines from Hollyhock’s episode from earlier. Thinking that she took them, he quickly flushes them all down the toilet as he lays on the floor and has a panic attack.
Later, as BoJack stares out the window, Beatrice asks where the girl is. BoJack says that she’s gone, to which Beatrice replies “Oh yes, I took her didn’t I?” (which is actually true, as she did take Hollyhock away from her mother). BoJack then tells his mother that he always hated her for being a horrible mother, and she was, but he blew it even worse. He says being a parent is impossible, so he can’t be that mad at her. Beatrice laughs and says “she” shouldn’t be mad at her , because it’s the right thing. BoJack wonders if maybe they deserve each other.
Beatrice gasps and asks again where the girl is, because she made the girl coffee. BoJack questions what is up with them and coffee. BoJack suddenly realizes something to his horror, and runs into the kitchen, shoving past his mother. He questions Beatrice what she put in the coffee, to which she replies with a bit of a devilish look ”That’s an old family secret!”. He goes under the cabinet and inside the bag with the coffee beans he finds a bottle of “Chubb Be Gone”, or weight loss supplements, revealing that Beatrice had been drugging Hollyhock with them to make her loose weight.
Beatrice says she was doing it only until she learned to take them herself (also because Beatrice herself took them when she was younger to stay skinny due to her being criticized for her weight as a little girl by her father and her school bully).
BoJack is enraged, which frightens Beatrice, and tells her her whole “not knowing where she is or who her son is” thing is not cute anymore, once again convinced she is faking her dementia. He says she ruined the one good thing he had and didn’t ruin by himself, but was ruined because he decided to give her another chance. Beatrice asks where Crackerjack is. BoJack angrily tells her she’s out of chances.
In a rage, he drives her to another nursing home and demands they put her in their worst possible room. We see the room is dimly lit, there are stains on the walls, and the window looks out to a dumpster. After the nurse leaves, BoJack codly tells his mother this is what her life has added up to, her by herself in this room. He says “Best of luck, see you never.” and begins lo leave. Beatrice asks who he is, and BoJack ignores her and says “Ug, bye Mom". There, Beatrice finally recognizes her son again, calling him by his name. (At the end of the next episode when she is scared and confused by her surroundings, BoJack goes back on his planned “Fuck you” speech, and ends up narrating her a summer from her childhood.)
“Time's Arrow” shows Beatrice’s backstory through her point of view, although due to her dementia some details are messed up, such as background characters having no faces or scenes or signs changing with a glitching noise. This is where we first meet the real Henrietta, who is remembered with a black scribble over her face. It is this episode we learn that Henrietta is Hollyhock’s mother, and that Butterscotch Horseman, BoJack’s father, is actually Hollyhock’s father, making her and BoJack half siblings.
“What Time Is It Right Now” shows BoJack sadly returning to his now empty house. He goes out onto his balcony and tries to call Hollyhock, but Steve, one of her dads, answers and angrily tells him to not call this number. BoJack tried to explain what really happened, saying it wasn’t Hollyhock’s fault, but Steve hangs up.
BoJack is watching reruns of his show again. Sabrina is upset at the Horse, and says “you’re supposed to be my dad! You’re supposed to be looking out for me! You’re the worst dad in the world!”.
BoJack gets up and heads to the kitchen, but he bumps into boxes of Beatrice’s stuff. While he looks through it, he calls the nursing home and tells them his mom’s stuff is still at his house, but to his frustration they put him on hold.
Another episode of Horsin Around plays, and Sabrina is wondering if she can find her real family using DNA. A lawyer tells her that DNA can belong to everyone in a family, like sons and fathers. BoJack turns the TV off.
BoJack is at Bellican’s Bar with Princess Carolyn. She is trying to tell him about Philbert, but he’s not having it, complaining about mysteries. She brings up how Matthew Perry was one of the actors considered for the roll. This makes BoJack flash back to a few months earlier. Hollyhock is trying to decide which photo she should send with the letter she’s writing to her mom for the adoption agency. She hopes they may have her address on file, and she doesn’t want this whole thing to end up like “Chandler’s List”, an SNL skit with Matthew Perry. It’s a parody of Schindler’s List, and at the end Chandler is distraught because he felt like he could have done more. BoJack leaves the bar and rushes home. He digs through his mother’s stuff and finds a pink envelope with the photo and letter Hollyhock wrote to her mom. He looks at the address and sees it was forwarded to his mother twice, and on the original address it includes someone named “Henrietta Platchkey”, although it says she no longer lives at the address
BoJack goes to Wichita, Kansas, Hollyhock’s hometown, and goes to Hollyhock’s house. After Dashawn opens the door BoJack barges in, pleading the still angry fathers to let him talk to Hollyhock. They tell him she’s not here and he shouldn’t have come here. BoJack pleads to let them listen to him for Hollyhock. They reluctantly agree.
BoJack begins to explain that the whole time Hollyhock was staying with him, it didn’t make sense, because if he was her father, where was her mother. He then got the idea that maybe he wasn’t her father. Steve tells him he isn’t, they’re her fathers, and the other dads surround BoJack. BoJack says he knows, but what he meant is that just because they had the same DNA, doesn’t mean that he’s her father. Jose begins to tell him he isn’t her father, and begins to talk about what a father really is, but BoJack cuts him off, frustrated they all keep jumping down his throat. BoJack reveals he is not Hollyhock’s father, his father, Butterscotch, is her father.
He went to every hospital and county clerks in Los Angeles, but he couldn't find any record of a baby horse born in 2000 in Los Angeles. This causes him to realize that his father might have knocked up one of the family maids, so he went back to San Francisco and found Hollyhock's birth certificate with Henrietta’s name on it. He then looked her up on Facebook and found her living in Minneapolis, Minnesota with her phone number attached to her account. BoJack shows the fathers the number saying he wants Hollyhock to have it, even stating he doesn't mind if they don't tell her how they got it, or if they tell Hollyhock he’s a terrible person and he never sees her again. After conversing in their own Dad Language, the fathers reluctantly agree to give it to her, but order BoJack to leave.
After BoJack returns home, Princess Carolyn visits, and he agrees to do Philbert. When she asks about him having a kid living with him, he says she has these adolpted dads. He thinks they’re dicks, but they take good care of her, and she’ll have a good life.
We later see him on his deck reading the script. It is there Hollyhock calls him again. She has gained her weight back, and she tells BoJack she wanted to thank him for finding her mom. She said she figured it out through her dads’ secret language, which they think she doesn’t understand but she thinks it’s super obvious what they’re saying. Hollyhock also reveals she’s been talking to Henrietta, who seems like a really nice person, and she’s flying out to Minneapolis to meet her.
She also complains that the airport charged her $10 for a fruit cup, and its 90% honeydew. BoJack angrily agrees with her on how terrible honeydew is, with Hollyhock saying it’s the Jared Leto of fruits.
As Hollyhock tells him they’re starting to board, BoJack apologizes for not taking better care of her. Hollyhock says moving in with him was too much too fast, but she still had a good time in LA, despite her getting drugged for months on end. BoJack says he really wanted to be a good father to her, and Hollyhock says he’s not actually her dad at all, which BoJack thinks is a good thing.
Hollyhock tells him she has to go. BoJack asks her things, like if she’s renting a car or if she wants her seat upgraded or better fruit. Hollyhock tells him she’s ok, and reminds him she never needed another dad, because she has eight of them. However, she says with a smile she never had a brother. This makes BoJack, for the first real time, smile, as he is deeply touched by finally making a loving family connection, something he never really had before.
Hollyhock is an intelligent young woman who finished her education early, and is currently taking a gap year. She understands her Dads' Dad Speak when they think she does not understand them, from which she was able to deduce that Bojack was the one responsible for finding her biological mother.
Aside from that, she isn't that different from a normal teenage girl. She's seeking, curious, smart, sweet, sarcastic, awkward and kind of dorky.
She also has aquired a few traits from BoJack; she’s a bit lazy as she does not help clean the house at all when Todd lies that she’s a maid and falls asleep twice, and she has enjoys eating and has a big appetite, as she claims she ate a whole box of donuts, and then later is seen finishing a whole personal pizza, and then eating a bag of chips. She also hates honeydew.
She also reveals in “Stupid Piece of Sh*t” she has a “tiny voice” in the back of her head that gives her negative, intrusive thoughts, such as telling her she’s worthless and stupid and ugly and everyone hates her, which is very similar to the anxiety induced inner monologues BoJack has throughout the episode. She believes it’s just a dumb teenage girl thing.
She is shown to have other insecurities like this throughout Season 4. In “The Judge” she has insecurities about her weight, saying the skinny voluptuous LA girls on the show BoJack is guest starring on makes her feel like a blob, and later BoJack inadvertently agrees with this when he’s trying to convince her Miles is a bad guy, offending and upsetting her.
At the end of the episode, (BoJack ended up being right about Miles, and he stopped contacting Hollyhock) she asks BoJack if a guy like Miles could really like someone like her and that if she’s pretty, and if he ever gets the feeling that to know you more is to love you less.
Unlike BoJack, however, she is willing to confront her emotions, as mentioned above she talks to him about her insecurities and anxieties, and she willingly starts crying in “Commence Fracking” when she thinks finding her mom is impossible, which is due to her dads telling her it’s ok to do so and to not feel bad about feeling bad.
She is seen doing odd things, such as lighting matches and throwing them into the pool, organizing all the coins in the house, and counting her teeth. One may originally think this is due to her dorky nature, but it is revealed it was from the amphetamines being snuck into her coffee by Beatrice.
She appears to be quite compassionate towards BoJack, as she asks him where he disappears to all day long and shows concern for him, and is forgiving towards his questionable actions. In turn, BoJack seems to be very protective of Hollyhock and constantly wants to look out for her, but also is scared to become close to her, as he believes he may poison her like everyone else in his life, or that his “poison” is already in her.
Despite her apparent laziness seen in her debut episode, she is very determined to find her mother, even asking dozens of women BoJack slept with in Hollywoo all by herself.
Although it was revealed that BoJack was not her biological father, but was in fact her half-brother; Season 4 concludes with her saying that she never had a brother before and indicated a desire to begin a loving sibling relationship with him.
- My name is Hollyhock Manheim-Mannheim-Guerrero-Robinson-Zilberschlag-Fonzerelli-McQuack.
- I know it’s confusing. I have 8 dads.
- No I was adopted... by 8 gay men in a committed gay polyamorous relationship
- But ever since I was a baby people always said I looked like BoJack Horseman...and I’ve always wondered if BoJack could be my biological...sperm...guy.
- No, but I am learning so much about my possibly maybe birth father! Like did you know has a shoebox in his closet full of bad reviews for other people’s TV shows?
- I also ate a box of doughnuts, got sleepy and took a nap.
- Look, I didn’t come all this way to not find out who my biological father is.
- No way! That sounds painful! Can’t we just use your hair?
- Oh wait! I have this whole comb full of hair in my bag! Duh!
- What? I’m helping! I’m cleaning out his DVR! Get it? Ok you got it right?
- Oh. Well that’s fine, I don’t want a relationship. I already have 8 dads. It’s not like a 9th dad is what I need to suddenly fill a hole in my life that the unconditional love of 8 dads couldn’t already fill.
- (Sarcastically) I’m sorry it’s so unpleasant for you to have to interact with women you were shitty to.
- I’m gonna do the rest of this on my own. I got the list. I don’t need you anymore. Have a bad life!.
- That Went Well (cameo)
- Hooray! Todd Episode! (official debut)
- Commence Fracking
- Thoughts and Prayers
- Stupid Piece of Sh*t
- The Judge
- Ruthie (mentioned throughout)
- Lovin that cali lifestyle!!
- Time's Arrow (cameo)
- What Time Is It Right Now
- Miles the Intern (dated)
- Her birth name is Girl Horse but was changed to Hollyhock Manheim-Mannheim-Guerrero-Robinson-Zilberschlag-Hsung-Fonzerelli-McQuack when adopted.
- She has eight adoptive fathers.
- She likes apples but she doesn't like applesauce.
- Like BoJack, she hates honeydew, describing it as the Jared Leto of fruits.
- She graduated from high school early and is taking a gap year.
- Despite her body type, she seems to be a bit athletic , as she has what appears to be a soccer trophy in her bedroom in "That Went Well", it is revealed she was the captain of her JV soccer team, in “Commence Fracking“ she is able to tuck and roll while sneaking through Marcy’s living room, and in "What Time Is It Right Now" she shows a photo of herself rollerblading.
- Hollyhock being secretly drugged by Beatrice with amphetamines in the coffee she makes her is hinted at multiple times
- The opening credits from “Stupid Piece of Sh*t” to “Lovin that cali lifestyle!!” show Hollyhock receiving coffee from Beatrice, whereas the first opening credit sequences she appears in (“Commence Fracking” and “Thoughts and Prayers”) shows her eating a Pop Tart.
- She is shown doing odd things such as lighting matches and throwing them into the pool, organizing all the coins she found in the house, seeing how fast she can change the TV channels, and counting her teeth. While this could initially be excused as social awkwardness, unusual behaviors are in fact a real life side affect of amphetamines.
- In “The Judge”, she says being cooped up in the house makes her feel like she has little bugs crawling around under her skin. Restlessness is another side effect.
- She rejects food twice, once at breakfast saying that she is good with her coffee, and at the very end of the episode, when BoJack asks if she wants to go out for pizza or ice cream. This is due to amphetamines taking away appetite, although some may originally think the last incident was due to Hollyhock being self conscious about her weight throughout the episode, and BoJack inadvertently agreeing with her that she was a “blob”.
- She is seen carrying her coffee thermos around more often, implying that she has become addicted to the drugs inside it.
- Hollyhock herself gradually loses weight.
- At the beginning of “Lovin that cali lifestyle!!”, Hollyhock appears very skinny, to the point that her clothes don’t fit her, she is dizzy, is acting anxious, and keeps scratching her neck and arms, all of which are side effects of amphetamines, until she eventually passes out from overdosing.
- It is implied that her birth mother Henrietta Platchkey actually did in fact want to raise her daughter but was forced by Beatrice to give the infant up for adoption.
- Season 4 ends with her telling BoJack while she already has plenty of paternal figures in her life, she would be content to have a sibling-like relationship with him.
- She enjoyed knocking people out with chloroform, mainly Todd Chavez.
- According to BoJack’s Instagram, after Season 4, Hollyhock went with BoJack to Hawaii and saw the Broadway show, Hamilton. This suggests that, despite Hollyhock's fathers forbidding BoJack from seeing her again, the two horses have hung out with each other afterwards. Another possibility is that her fathers have forgiven BoJack and lifted the ban on him interacting with Hollyhock.
- This has been proven true, as in February 2018 BoJack posted a picture on Instagram  of him watching the Super Bowl at Hollyhock’s House with her and her eight dads.