Andrew Garfield is a young adult human male with dark brown hair that poofs up at the top of his head. He wears a light blue collared shirt, a dark green sweater over it, dark brown blue pants, white socks, and brown loafers. He has a big nose and long neck. He also appears to be quite tall.
- In the series he is stated to like lasagna and hate Mondays like the titular character from the comic strip Garfield-which may be a play on his Surname.
- He dated Sarah Lynn in Season 1, he breaks up with her, causing her to a have a emotional melt down at the mall. She impales herself, and defecates on a couch.
- He is injured in Later, where he is seen in the hospital, with Sarah Lynn comforting him, presumably having gotten back together with him.
- A consequence of a famous person refusing to portray their animated counterpart in the Bojack Universe is some bad fortune will fall on their cartoon selves-this is an example of this happening.